Brown Recluse vs Hobo Spider

The quick tellA recluse has a violin mark and plain legs. A hobo spider has a herringbone pattern on the abdomen and lives in a funnel web. The two barely share any states.
Brown recluse (Loxosceles reclusa)

Photo: Br-recluse-guy, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

Brown recluse

Medically significant · Loxosceles reclusa

  • Dark violin shape on the back, neck of the violin points to the rear
  • Six eyes in three pairs (most spiders have eight)
  • Plain tan abdomen and legs with no bands or spines
  • Long thin legs; with legs spread it is about the size of a quarter

Size: 0.25–0.5 in. Habitat: Indoors in boxes, closets, attics and basements; outdoors under rocks and bark.

Most bites heal without trouble; a few cause a slow-healing wound. Many wounds blamed on recluses outside their range turn out to be other conditions.

Hobo spider (Eratigena agrestis)

Photo: Géry PARENT, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Hobo spider

Harmless · Eratigena agrestis

  • Brown funnel-web spider with a herringbone pattern on the abdomen
  • Plain brown legs
  • Funnel-shaped web in window wells, wood piles and basements

Size: 0.4–0.6 in. Habitat: Pacific Northwest and the northern Rockies; introduced from Europe.

Once blamed for wounds like a recluse bite. Later studies found no evidence that its bite causes them.

Where each one lives

Alabama: Brown recluse onlyAlaska: neitherArizona: neitherArkansas: Brown recluse onlyCalifornia: neitherColorado: Hobo spider onlyConnecticut: neitherDelaware: neitherFlorida: neitherGeorgia: Brown recluse onlyHawaii: neitherIdaho: Hobo spider onlyIllinois: Brown recluse onlyIndiana: Brown recluse onlyIowa: Brown recluse onlyKansas: Brown recluse onlyKentucky: Brown recluse onlyLouisiana: Brown recluse onlyMaine: neitherMaryland: neitherMassachusetts: neitherMichigan: neitherMinnesota: neitherMississippi: Brown recluse onlyMissouri: Brown recluse onlyMontana: Hobo spider onlyNebraska: Brown recluse onlyNevada: neitherNew Hampshire: neitherNew Jersey: neitherNew Mexico: neitherNew York: neitherNorth Carolina: neitherNorth Dakota: neitherOhio: Brown recluse onlyOklahoma: Brown recluse onlyOregon: Hobo spider onlyPennsylvania: neitherRhode Island: neitherSouth Carolina: neitherSouth Dakota: neitherTennessee: Brown recluse onlyTexas: Brown recluse onlyUtah: Hobo spider onlyVermont: neitherVirginia: neitherWashington: Hobo spider onlyWest Virginia: neitherWisconsin: neitherWyoming: neither
Brown recluse: 16 states. Hobo spider: 6 states. Their ranges do not overlap.

Side by side

Brown recluseHobo spider
DangerMedically significantHarmless
Size0.25–0.5 in0.4–0.6 in
States166
HabitatIndoors in boxes, closets, attics and basements; outdoors under rocks and barkPacific Northwest and the northern Rockies; introduced from Europe

Questions

How can you tell a brown recluse from a hobo spider?

A recluse has a violin mark and plain legs. A hobo spider has a herringbone pattern on the abdomen and lives in a funnel web. The two barely share any states.

Which one is dangerous?

The brown recluse: medically significant. The hobo spider: harmless. If you are not sure, keep your distance and do not handle it.

Where do both live?

Their ranges do not overlap in any state, which helps with identification.

More look-alikes